[Review] and [Comparison] – YSL Rouge Pur Couture in #52 Rosy Coral vs #51 Corail Urbain

I think YSL lipsticks need no introduction, right?  I actually got to know how famous they were through a Korean drama called “My Love From Another Star” starring Jun Ji Hyun and Kim Soo Hyun.  In short, it is a love story between a 400-year-old alien (but very handsome) guy and a snobbish but beautiful actress.  Sounds crazy I know, but go watch the first few episodes and see why the entire world is going crazy over Korean national goddess Jun Ji Hyun’s #52 Rosy Coral lips!

I did not own any YSL lipsticks before the drama but when I was interested, I found out the shade #52 Rosy Coral is sold out worldwide!  It’s been over a year since the drama ended, and I tell you, even now it is still not easy to lay your hands on this shade.  Madness!  That is how I settled on #51 Corail Urbain which was a similar shade while waiting for stock of #52…. I sure waited long!

Brand:    Yves Saint Lauren (YSL)
Product:  Rouge Pur Couture Lipstick
Shade:    52 Rosy Coral and 51 Corail Urbain 
Price:    USD 35
Type:     Lipstick
Size:     20g
Origin:   Made in France
Website:  YSL website
THE PACKAGING

A classy reflective gold square casing.  Can serve somewhat as a mirror 🙂

Beautiful YSL carving on the lipstick itself.  What a gorgeous coral shade! So bright, almost neon isn’t it?

The #51 shade has a dark red YSL wording on the casing – instead of black on #52.  Maybe because #51 was a 2013 autumn limited shade? But I believe it has become their normal range already so both #51 and #52 is not considered limited edition.

 

THE PRODUCT

According to YSL:

“A new-generation lipstick inspired by Monsieur Saint Laurent’s iconic color palette—red, fuchsia and orange—in a collection of captivating couture shades that offer each complexion a customized look. Lips are saturated with intense, stay-true color, thanks to the Coloreveal Technology while natural extracts provide comforting moisture that lasts all day. Provides medium to full coverage with a radiant, satin finish.”

I heart matte lipsticks over glossy ones, so Rouge Pur Couture is one of my favourites!  I won’t say the texture is “moisturizing” as it does dry up to form a matte finish with some radiance – although that “radiance” is also gone after an hour or so.  It will still leave a stain on your lips after fading, and by far, this is one of the most long-lasting lipsticks I have tried so can’t complain XD

SWATCHES

Ooooh… now you can see the difference in shade. #52 is much deeper brighter coral shade, and #51 is more on the peachy pink light coral shade.  I love both!

Both are buildable in intensity to be opaque, and you can see that multiple layers of #52 can turn into a very intense coral shade – suitable for a special night or occasion 🙂

On the lips!  #51 is a nice peachy coral suitable for daily wear, while #52 is more intense as it has more rose red pigment.

Personally #52 is too “bright” for me as a daily wear – I think if I walk into office with those lips, my colleagues will ask “did something happen to you?” with shocked expressions on their face LOLxxx.  But #51 is perfect!  Brightens up the complexion and provides sweet colour to the face 🙂

MY VERDICT

Pros

  • High high pigmentation
  • Smooth texture, glidable on lips
  • Semi-matte finish with slight glow/sheen  (I like matte stuff)
  • Considered long lasting of about 4~5 hours (the high pigmentation will leave a tint on your lips even after it fades out – especially #52)

Cons

  • Glides on easy but can feel abit dry afterwards
  • Some accentuation on lip lines (applying lip balm or primer before helps)
  • May need lip brush to apply #52 as prone to bleeding if not careful (#51 could be fine without lip brush unless you want it more defined)

Overall

Both lipsticks belong to the same range so they are similar in texture and finish.  Pigmentation wise, #52 is clearly a stronger, more intense colour while #51 belongs to a more peachy light coral family.  I adore both these lippies very much 🙂

Both colours are very wearable on any day, and can be buildable to its desired intensity.  I like to wear #51 on my lips overall, then dab #52 in the inner corners to create gradient lips!  Which do you like better? ^^